Electric Skillet Hamburgers

Electric Skillet Hamburgers

Straight out of my husband’s mouth

“Jessica, this is such a GOOD burger. So good.”

My husband doesn’t just tell me what I want to hear when it comes to my cooking and/or recipes. So when he goes on and on about how good something is, you better believe I’m going to call it the BEST.

Don’t miss the SUPER popular and Fantabulosity fan favorite, the Hamburgers in the Oven recipe and the NEW Smoked Burgers recipe!

Browned Butter Cheeseburger Recipe

Right along with Fantabulosity recipe tradition, we’re gonna keep things easy.

I’m not a gourmet chef, and sometimes simple is better. So you can count on this recipe only using ingredients that you more than likely have on hand and can be whipped up in just a short time.

For YEARS, I made a not-so-appetizing cheeseburger. No lie. They were dry, unflavorful (is that a word), and just “edible.” Now, we have them once a week, and look forward to “cheeseburger day” and I can’t help but think that these are so delicious because of the browned butter (like we use when cooking steaks in the oven) and “steaming” effect that the electric skillet gives!

Best Cheeseburger Recipe Photo Tutorial

Don’t let all of the photos scare you. There aren’t many steps to these! I just wanted to be extra thorough for you!

For the full recipe with measurements, you can see the recipe card towards the end of the post!

Get the Skillet Ready

Butter (REAL butter… not that fake stuff), Peppercorn, Garlic Powder, and Kosher Salt. Ahh… a heavenly mix, wouldn’t you say?

Using an electric skillet, heat it to 350 degrees, and then coat the skillet with about 2-3 Tablespoons of butter. (You can also cut a chunk of butter and toss it in. I just secretly love sliding the butter back and forth, and enjoying the moment.)

While your butter is browning (this is KEY… BROWN THAT BUTTER), patty out the burgers.

If you don’t have an electric skillet, you can cook burgers on the stovetop in a frying pan!

Prep the burgers

1 lb of ground beef usually makes three burgers for us. (We like them thick.)

Roll a third of the ground beef into a ball, and then mash down into a patty using both hands. Using your thumbs and fingers… smooth out the edges the best that you can, making sure there are little or NO cracks. This will help hold the juices in, and keep it from falling apart.

I also push down a bit in the center of each hamburger patty, to allow the juices to flow towards the middle while cooking, rather than running off of the sides and into the skillet.

What Temperature do You Cook Hamburgers in an Electric Skillet?

Put the lid on the electric skillet, and let the burgers cook over 350 for a couple of minutes, or until the tops start turning a grayish/light brown, and the bottoms have a BEAUTIFUL brown color to them.

Flip the burgers.

Put the lid back on, and let them cook a few minutes more.

The photo above shows an example of how they’re NOT done. The juices coming out of the top are still pink/red.

Now, THIS is how you know they’re done. The juices coming out of the top have changed colors to the grayish/tan.

What Kind of Cheese for Cheeseburger

Turn the electric skillet on simmer, and place a slice of cheese over each burger.

(Here, I used provolone and American, just because we had the extra cheese on hand and I wanted to see how it would taste. It was good, but I’m still a fan of American cheese on a burger.)

Place the lid back on, and let the cheese slowly melt on to each burger.

How to Toast Hamburger Buns

Ok, I know it looks nasty. But pouring out the grease/butter into a bowl from the electric skillet is what needs to be done, to get it ready for the buns.

Pour most of it out, but it’s a-ok if you leave behind some of the seasoning/grease/hamburger pieces. This just adds more flavor to your buns.)

Coat the skillet again with butter (turning the skillet up to about 300 degrees) and place each half of the buns on the skillet.)

The buns should toast in about 30 seconds, and they’ll have this glorious brownish/black look.

Your burgers are ready for assembly!

How to Make the BEST Cheeseburgers

This is totally optional, but one of the things my family loves is when I assemble the burgers (without toppings or condiments) and wrap each cheeseburger in aluminum foil and let them sit for about 5 or 10 minutes before serving.

What this does is “steams” the burgers and connects the burgers, cheese and buns for a DELICIOUS texture.

Then, my family will put their toppings or condiments of choice and enjoy!

Cheeseburger Toppings

Top your cheeseburger with some of our favorites and other goodies like:

• Tomatoes
• Bacon
• Red Onions
• Lettuce
• Mustard
• Honey Mustard
• Spicy Mustard
• Ketchup
• Mayo
• Pickles
• Avocado
• Spicy or Fiesta Ranch
• Crispy Fried Onions
• Fried Egg
• BBQ Sauce
• Sriracha
• Steak Sauce (like A1)
• Carmalized Onions
• Peppers
• Hummus
•  Hot Sauce
• Relish
• Spinach Leaves
• Slaw
• Chips
• Jalapenos
• Grilled Pineapple
• Teriyaki Sauce
• Queso
• Crumbled Blue Cheese
• Chili

I hope you enjoy them as much as my husband and my boys! Another quick and easy recipe that’s a house favorite… in the books! Thanks for stopping by and don’t forget to check out my other “BEST’S” recipes like my:

The BEST Side Salad Recipe

BEST Beef Tenderloin Recipe

The BEST Guacamole Recipe

Pin this cheeseburger recipe for later when you need it: